r/moviecritic • u/tiger2mighty • 12h ago
What critically acclaimed movie do you think is SEVERELY FLAWED
I’ll start: Past Lives
I have always hated Past Lives from the start; however, I thought I owed it to myself and the film community to give it another watch. Unfortunately, I think I hate it more now. The crux of the issue is that Celine Song is not as talented as people think she is. As in, she can’t handle nuanced topics at all.
Past Lives, at the very core of it, is a film about missed opportunities and cultural connections to an old life of yours. Fine. However, if that is the angle she wanted to go with, Arthur, Nora’s husband, was a shambolic character who completely ruined the movie and its tone. Song attempts to write Arthur as this understanding husband who just wants to create space for Nora as she navigates this. However, it completely backfires because Song has no idea what a supportive husband looks like, and, as a result, makes him look like a total cuckold.
Openly disrespecting your husband by talking in another language (yes, this is disrespectful as someone who can speak 7 languages) on paper seems like she is attempting to reconnect with her culture and have a better understanding of it. However, it does not allow her the room to actually grow as a character. In fact, I think the movie completely skips the growth. It makes us as the audience assume that she grew because she let Hae Sung go. Arthur doesn't show any resistance. There could be a conflict where both of them grow. But Arthur’s existence is purely a humiliation ritual. Song writes Arthur specifically to cuck him. And then suddenly Nora wants to stay behind in Canada.
Like I said, the concept of the film isn’t terrible; it’s just that Song is not nearly as talented as people think she is at bringing the idea to light. A director like Joachim tried can handle nuance like this much better.
Look forward to having a good faith discussion!
2.5/5 stars